Carey Price signs for 2 years
No "strike". Two weeks before training camp. A reported $5.5m total.
Panic averted. Our top player under 25 (feature up tomorrow) is in the fold. How novel.
Habs Top 25 Under 25: 5-2
Yeah, we're going to stretch this out just a little bit longer. Of course, by the end of this piece, it should be pretty obvious who we collectively think is the best player under 25 in the organization, but we'll be giving him his own feature regardless. In the meantime, have a look back at the series from the start: the Introduction, #25-21, #20-16, #15-11, and #10-6. Also, another special thanks are due to the crew at the Copper & Blue (yes, I'm a poet and I do know it) for the concept.
#5: Louis Leblanc, C, 19 years old
He's the man who possesses probably the greatest hockey name on this entire list, and he's already a bit of a local legend despite not playing any meaningful games in Canada for the past two years. That will all change this fall, as Leblanc looks to join the list of famous Harvard dropouts such as Bill Gates, Howard Hughes, Robert Frost, and Matt Damon. But it's not like we're putting unrealistic expectations on him or anything... right?
Leblanc will start his post-Crimson journey wearing the decidedly less pretentious maroon of the Montreal Junior Hockey Club after turning professional by signing a 3 year entry level contract with the Montreal Canadiens this August. The year in Verdun should help prepare him for the professional schedule, the media demands of Montreal, and to put him in top form in time for the Canadian U20 World Junior Championships, a team he is expected to make after being a late cut last year. He's already helped the QMJHL team become a hot ticket in Montreal, as the Juniors have already sold out a handful of regular season games well before the start of the season. All this for a player few have actually been able to see play, albeit one that was picked 18th overall by the Canadiens just a year ago.
Leblanc was the 1st overall pick in the 2007 QMJHL midget draft by Val D'Or, even though he had indicated he was not going the major junior route and pursue his education at Harvard. This forced Leblanc to spend another year playing AAA Midget hockey before going to Omaha to join the USHL's Lancers in his NHL draft year (2008-09). This lack of exposure might be the reason the scouting reports on him are quite mixed. Some say his speed is one of his best assets, but others view it as merely average. For what it's worth, when I saw him play at the 2009 U20 Evaluation Camp in Saskatoon, where he played left wing on a line with Matt Duchene, he always seemed to gain a step on the defenders and cause problems with his acceleration. Perhaps not surprisingly for a man who was admitted to Harvard, his hockey smarts are well regarded by everyone, with buzz words like 'crafty' and 'great vision' making frequent appearances in scouting summaries. Rich Michalowski of Premium Scouting sees him as a player in the Sam Gagner mould, a strong two-way talent who will need to develop physically to become a successful pro. His junior coach, Pascal Vincent, sees a lot of Mike Richards in him.
Bonne fête Jean! - A Beliveau Birthday Link Bonanza
Tomorrow, August 31, 2010, Canadiens legend Jean Beliveau turns 79 in Earth years, but he is a man whose life is as timeless as his legend is eternal.
In Act One of Beliveau's time, he was a graceful and skilled hockey player, a dazzling talent who helped the Canadiens to ten Stanley Cups. He was an exempliary leader on the ice and a role model beyond its bounds. His career in hockey could be said to have been unparalleled.
In Act Two of Jean's time, he parlayed all that the game of hockey did to benefit him, and gracefully and generously used it to the benefit of others through endless acts of charity though his foundation's name and via others. You could look him up under the word "integrity".
As a present to Beliveau fans, especially the younger ones who may not have had the chance to see him play or learn much about him, below are 79 links to explore Le Gros Bill's life and times. (You won't read them all today so I will throw a link to this article in the sidebar so you can check it out when you have the time.)
Habs Top 25 Under 25: 10-6
Now we're really getting into the heart of the matter. Actual NHL players, top prospects, and recent acquisitions appear on the list as we look at the top 10 Montreal Canadiens under the age of 25. To view the rest of the list, here are players 25-21, 20-16, 15-11 and the introductory piece.
#10: Dustin Boyd, C, 24 years old
Acquired in the trade that sent Sergei Kostitsyn to the Nashville Predators, Boyd is a young centre who had a very strong WHL career and made an appearance for Canada at the 2006 U20 World Junior Championships, where he was teammates with current Canadiens Benoit Pouliot and Tom Pyatt, as well as former Canadiens Kyle Chipchura and Guillaume Latendresse. He was second in scoring on that team to Blake Comeau, with four goals and two assists in six games. Since turning pro, Boyd has played in 210 NHL regular season games, plus 9 playoff games, more than anyone else under 25 in the Canadiens' organization. He hasn't found his scoring touch at this level, however, topping out at 11 goals and 24 points last year with the Calgary Flames and Nashville.
Boyd is an effective defensive player, posting the lowest GA/60 minute figure on Calgary before being traded. He has good speed, and posted the best faceoff numbers of his career after being traded to Nashville. That could be nothing more than a hot streak, because his career faceoff numbers aren't very impressive. For the time being, he's penciled in on either the 3rd or 4th line out of training camp, a role he hasn't escaped so far in his career. Will he be as productive as Sergei Kostitsyn? Probably not, but considering he was a player who forced himself out of town, the Habs could've done worse in getting Boyd in return.
#9: Tom Pyatt, LW/C, 23 years old
Acquired as part of the Scott Gomez trade with the New York Rangers last summer, Pyatt surprised many observers out of training camp by making a push for a roster spot. Eventually, Pyatt forced his way into the regular lineup, a feat that is noteworthy despite the opening night presence of Georges Laraque as an everyday player. Pyatt's game is all about the details: good skating, strong backchecking, aggressive puck pursuit and getting in the passing lanes. It translates well into penalty killing, and he was taking a regular shift on the PK by season's end and into the playoffs.
Pyatt's obvious weakness: his offensive game. He recorded only 5 points in 40 NHL games last year, plus 4 points in 18 playoff games. It's unlikely he'll ever threaten for a spot in the top 6, but some kind of scoring ability is appreciated even from the final 2 lines. He'll have to focus extensively on excelling as a defensive player as a result. He's also a potential Lady Byng candidate: He's recorded only 36 PIM in 156 AHL games, and won the OHL's Most Sportsmanlike player in 2006-07 with only 18 PIMs in 58 games, to go along with 81 points. Most Byng winners are also offensive stars, so Pyatt probably has some work to do in other regards if he's to achieve that kind of accolades as a NHLer.
Habs Top 25 Under 25: 15-11
The next group of five players were pretty hotly contested amongst our panel. They include several players that appeared in Montreal's lineup at some point during the 2009-10 NHL season, and the panel at large walked away with mixed opinions on their future as a result. Also gracing the list is a well regarded new addition to the team, who the panel hasn't yet formed conclusive opinion on. For players 25-21, click here. For players 20-16, click here. To re-introduce yourself to the panel and the concept of the Top 25 Under 25, click here.
#15: Mathieu Carle, D, 22 years old
After three seasons of apprenticeship in Hamilton, Mathieu Carle is at a crossroads in his career with the Canadiens. A puckmoving blueliner with a right handed shot, Carle has a lot going for him. That's not to mention the fact that he's one of a few Quebecois players in the Habs system that is on the cusp of the NHL. Unfortunately for Carle, what was developing into a breakthrough season was cut short due to injury, something that has held him back in the past. Carle had 15 points in 31 games in Hamilton last year, while being deployed by coach Guy Boucher as his number 1 blueliner to start the year. The role of #1 blueliner was eventually fulfilled by P.K. Subban, who seized the opportunity and now looks to have a regular spot in the 2010-11 Canadiens starting lineup.
Carle isn't blessed with great size, but he's the kind of blueliner that can fill a nice role on the team's bottom pairing if all works out. There is a spot open on the Habs blueline to start the year with the injury to Andrei Markov, but the acquisition of Alexandre Picard makes Carle's chances of cracking the roster on opening night that much more difficult. Carle doesn't possess the PP skills that Picard does, which may be the final factor in sending him back to Hamilton. He would have to clear waivers in order to do so, but with only 3 NHL games and coming off an injury, he's a safe bet to clear waivers after training camp. That is, unless Boucher backs up his assertion last year that Carle was NHL ready and requests the Lightning to take a chance on him.
#14: Ben Maxwell, C, 22 years old
Maxwell ended last season on the Canadiens roster, a late season injury callup who didn't get into much action and was caught in a numbers game with regards to the CBA, which only allows a certain amount of demotions and callups after the trade deadline. He had injury concerns in junior, but has overcome those as a professional with back-to-back healthy seasons. He has progressed steadily at the AHL level, posting 58 points in 73 games as a rookie and 44 points in 57 games as a sophomore. However, in 21 NHL games to date (1 in the playoffs), he has yet to record his first NHL point.
Maxwell is a playmaking centre who can play the high forward position on the powerplay, and even the point if need be. He likes to have control of the play, allowing his teammates to gain favourable positions to lead an offensive attack. He has good skating skills and a decent wrist shot. With the additions of Lars Eller and Dustin Boyd, Maxwell is likely ticketed to Hamilton where he will battle it out with David Desharnais for the top centre spot. He remains eligible to be classified as a rookie for the 2010-11 NHL season, despite playing 21 games over the past 2 years in the NHL.
Habs Top 25 Under 25: 20-16
In this next group of youngsters, we're starting to hit up some names more familiar to Habs fans, and at #18, we start to hit the range where all panelists were in agreement that the player was one of the 25 best in the organization. We're starting to move away from the question marks and into the guys we all see as potential players for the team at some point, if not already. To view players 25-21, click here. For an introduction to the Top 25 Under 25 concept, click here.
#20: Ian Schultz, RW, 20 years old
Fresh off captaining the Calgary Hitmen to a WHL Championship and a 3rd place finish at the Memorial Cup, Schultz was ready to turn professional in the St. Louis Blues' organization. However, management of the Blues and the Canadiens had other plans, and he was included as one half of the Jaroslav Halak return. Schultz is a big, physical winger who will probably need to make the NHL as much with his fists as with his skates. However, at this point at least, he looks to be more than a potential goon. The younger brother of Washington Capitals defenseman Jeff Schultz, he's proven to be a solid goal scorer at the junior level, notching 33 goals over 93 regular season and playoff games last year in a complimentary role. He also racked up 150 PIMS, so the power forward potential is certainly there, although not at an elite level.
The upside on Schultz isn't huge, but he's a safe bet to devleop into a good AHLer and potentially a bottom 6 NHL forward. Where he'll have to excel in the future is the defensive side of the game, showing he won't be a hindrance to his teammates on the ice while maintaining his physical edge. If all goes well, Schultz has the potential to develop into a fan favourite. Maybe not quite the fan favourite level of the guy he was traded for, but a well liked teammate none the less.
#19: David Desharnais, C, 24 years old
There are quite a number of things that stick out about David Desharnais. The first thing people may notice is his size... or lack there of. Desharnais is all of 5'7", 176 lbs., and that height is likely measured with the skates on. The second thing that sticks out are the much higher numbers on his stat line: 2 100 point seasons in the QMJHL, 1 100 point season in the ECHL, and a 100 point pace last year in the AHL (78 points in 60 games). His puck skill and playmaking smarts put him in an elite class amongst AHLers, but there are legitimate concerns over whether he can transfer those skills at the NHL level, where the game is quicker and the opponents are that much stronger.
Desharnais main drawbacks, aside from his size, are his skating ability (described as merely average) and his defensive play. Brian La Rose of Habsworld thinks the key to him making it in the Habs organization could be how new Hamilton Head Coach Randy Cunneyworth deploys him next season, suggesting he try him out in a defensive role. "The road to the NHL, on any team, almost always begins on the bottom line. If Desharnais' defence improves, he may very well have a legit shot down the road somewhere." Desharnais has an outside shot at making the Habs out of training camp, but more than likely will be sent back to Hamilton for one more year, as he is waiver exempt. He made his NHL debut this past year, playing in 6 games and earning 1 point for the Habs.
Habs Top 25 Under 25: 25-21
Late yesterday, I introduced EOTP's Habs Top 25 Under 25 project. It's based on the series The Copper & Blue have been doing this year, and I've recruited all of EOTP's writers as well as some outside help in the form of Topham from Lions in Winter and Brian La Rose of Habsworld.net. The only requirements for all players in this ranking is that they must be under 25 as of Sept. 15, 2010, and the Montreal Canadiens must hold their NHL rights. These are the results of the votes cast by each panelist, weighted equally.
The following players are either viewed as longshots by the panel, or they are players that are well out of the limelight but possess legitimate potential. All five of the players did not garner a top 25 placement from every panelist, and there was generally a wide range of opinion amongst the panelists who put the player on their ballot. Over and over again, the idea of whether a player was likely to make an impact on the Habs roster was prominent in the panelists minds.
#25: Maxim Trunev, RW, 20 years old
Trunev is a bit of a question mark going forward, as he currently plays for Severstal Cherepovets of the KHL. He has progressed nicely through the Russian junior ranks, and due to the lack of a transfer agreement between the KHL and NHL, the Habs hold his NHL rights indefinitely, allowing them exclusivity to sign him when his KHL contract expires. Trunev was taken 3rd overall in the 2008 CHL Import Draft by the Portland Winterhawks of the WHL, but never reported due to his KHL contract. He made his IIHF debut this past year at the U20 World Junior Championships in Saskatoon and Regina, tallying 4 points in 6 games on Team Russia's second line.
Trunev's greatest assets are his speed and shot. While he has yet to be placed in a scoring role in the KHL, he projects very well there to become a top line forward. He likes to lead offensive rushes across the blue line and drive to the net, but he tends to stick to the perimeter when his team is setting up in the offensive zone. He doesn't possess great size, but he's big enough that his size won't be a factor in holding him back. He's still quite young, as he will only turn 20 on Sept. 7, so there is still good reason to keep an eye on his development in the coming years. Of course, whether or not he'll commit himself to leaving a potentially lucrative KHL career for a shot at making the Montreal Canadiens has yet to be seen. There are currently no talks to bring him over.
Habs Top 25 Under 25: Introduction
If you're a follower of SB Nation, you may be already aware of this concept. The Edmonton Oilers blog, The Copper & Blue, has run this twice in the past year as a look ahead for their team's future. So, with training camp coming up next month, I figured it'd be a good idea to poll the talent here at Eyes on the Prize to see what we thought, good or bad, about the guys our favourite team has in the same group. We're hardly perfect guys for the job, we aren't scouts for anyone currently, but we're passionate followers of the team and always keep an eye out for talent that could help the team win games down the line.
But first a few words about the concept. Top 25 Under 25 is about comparing players based on their age, not their pro hockey experience. When you eliminate players that are already contributing NHLers, you don't always give an accurate depiction of what the future of the team entails. All players that are signed to a NHL contract are under the control of their parent team until at least age 25... players cannot become UFA's before that age unless the team decides to buy them out or not submit a qualifying offer on their contract. The Habs actually possess two players that were not qualified by their teams this June: Benoit Pouliot and Dustin Boyd. But come next year, the Habs will again have the option of qualifying both those players based on their current deals.
It also is pretty common knowledge that players don't reach their peak production years until about the age of 25. They might be as good as they're going to be at age 21... we can't say that with 100% certainty that they will improve. But it's reasonable to assume players will get better if they are under 25 years old. Once they hit 25, that becomes less likely. It's a good age to use as a measuring stick.
So we're looking at players that will be under 25 on Sept. 15. Sept. 15 is the date that, in a player's draft year, they use as a cutoff. Each entry draft pits players that will turn 18 between Sept. 16 the previous calendar year and Sept. 15 of the current year. It also is an approximate starting point for NHL training camps, meaning no player can report to a training camp before their 18th birthday (at least roughly).
Each panelist was asked to submit their own top 25. Each player was then given points for their placement: 1st place got 25 points, 2nd place 24 points, and so on down to 25th place getting 1 point. I then took out the highest and lowest scores of each player to eliminate any potential personal bias to arrive with a total that reflects the general assessment of the panel. This last step did very little to change the results, and really only had an effect on the lower ranked players, but the players at the lower end ended up being guys generally liked by the majority of the panelists. Just as an added note, it should be known that new acquisition Karri Ramo was not included in the ranking, as the voting was originally done with Cedric Desjardins involved. His votes were discounted and we didn't bother to include Ramo due to the group not being familiar enough with him at this point.
For the list itself, click here for players 25-21, here for players 20-16, and here for 15-11.
And now, without further ado, the EOTP scouts:











by 









































































