While creating my top 25 list, I realized that the players which I had the most trouble ranking were, to some extent, boom or bust propositions.
These difficult to sort players fell largely into two categories:
Players that I might be ranking too high:
These players have been drafted high or have been hyped up due to accolades they'd received since being drafted. Examples include KK, Guhle, Primeau, Harris, Norlinder, and Poehling.
Players whom I might have ranked too low:
These players were not first rounders and may have received less attention than others despite producing some impressive numbers.
Examples include: Mysak, Tuch, Farrell, Dobes, Gordin, and Roy.
*I'm aware of Farrell's award winning season, but I still think it largely flies under the radar.