Top 25 Boom or Bust

While creating my top 25 list, I realized that the players which I had the most trouble ranking were, to some extent, boom or bust propositions.

These difficult to sort players fell largely into two categories:

Players that I might be ranking too high:

These players have been drafted high or have been hyped up due to accolades they'd received since being drafted. Examples include KK, Guhle, Primeau, Harris, Norlinder, and Poehling.


Players whom I might have ranked too low:

These players were not first rounders and may have received less attention than others despite producing some impressive numbers.

Examples include: Mysak, Tuch, Farrell, Dobes, Gordin, and Roy.

*I'm aware of Farrell's award winning season, but I still think it largely flies under the radar.

Comment below:

Who are the biggest boom or bust players in the top 25?

Fanpost content is created by members of the community. Views and opinions presented do not necessarily reflect those of Eyes on the Prize's authors, editors, or managers.