clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

10 Costly Mistakes Made by The Canadiens Since1977

I've often wondered if history could be undone, what the result would be on the present.

Applying such a "Back To The Future" angle on the history of the Montreal Canadiens allows one to reconsider many events that transpired over the course of the last 30 years.

Using 20/20 hindsight is no brave musing - sports fans are well accustomed to being Monday morning quarterbacks. It is fairly easy to identify what has gone wrong in any era of a sports franchise. In terms of the Canadiens spiral from Stanley Cup dynasty of the late seventies to the average team of today, many errors in judgement have resulted in the team being a middle of the pack squad.

Often the Canadiens of recent years have been afflicted with terms such as "once proud", "hard luck", and "falling from grace or glory", so much so that one would confuse them with the Maple Leafs or the Islanders. While Montreal sat outside the playoff picture this spring, their so called decline, in perspective, is far from being as catastrophic as some would have believe.

Since 1979, and with the NHL adding 12 new franchises, every teams odds of winning the Stanley Cup have decreased proportionately. In the 27 seasons played since then, only the Islanders, Edmonton Oilers, Detroit Red Wings and New Jersey Devils won won more Cups. Colorado and Pittsburgh, as well as Montreal, are the only other teams with multiple Cups. Five other franchises have won single Cups.

If most franchises were dealt the fate of winning but one Stanley Cup per decade, they'd gladly accept that fate. Not in Montreal, where expectations are constantly high, and errors are scrutinized beyond the realm of understanding in most NHL cities.

If only one of the following errors of judgement from the past were to be undone, it would have greatly affected the teams future. Each mistake had pronouced consequences which led to the weakening of team over the years.

It is, of course, futile in a sense, to dwell on those errors - the only upside of going over them is to recognize when they are about to occur again and avoiding them the next time around.
Chronologically, here are 10 mistakes any Hab fan would wince at in hindsight.

10 - Not choosing Mike Bossy in the 1977 Entry Draft.

Who knew that Bossy would string off 9 straight 50 goal seasons in the NHL? Canadiens head scout Ron Caron had an inkling when he pronounced to GM Sam Pollock that he'd found the next Guy Lafleur. Fourteen teams passed on Bossy before the Islanders wisely chose him. Bossy was considered by many to be a soft player in a softer league and many disregarded the compass in his eye. From 1973 to 1977, Bossy rifled off seasons of 70, 84, 79, and 75 with the Laval National of the QMJHL. Still many NHL teams passed on him, including Toronto twice with back to back picks at 11 and 12. The Canadiens opted for a fairly decent player, the Toronto Marlborough's Mark Napier, who would give them a pair of 40 goal season before being packaged off to Minnesota for center Bobby Smith. It was often suggested in hindsight that Bossy would never have met the same fate in Montreal, that a sniper with defensive laxes would have taken too long to find his place in Montreal. I never bought that angle. Five years prior, the Habs drafted a similar player in Steve Shutt. While Shutt's ascent was steady, not immediate, who's to suggest it could not have been the same for Bossy.

9 - Choosing Irving Grundman over Scotty Bowman to succeed Sam Pollock as the Canadiens GM.

Grundman was not a sound hockey man in the eyes of many, often being termed a glorified bowling alley manager by most. He was chosen to succed Sam Pollock based on the fear of what Scotty Bowman, if handed the position, would do to the team, which was dismantle it piece by aging piece. He had been being groomed for the job by Pollock himself before the reigns were turned over in 1978. The Canadiens upper brass wanted Pollock to stay on for a longer term and hoped that Bowman would do so also. With Bowman having little faith in Grundman's capabilities he left after two seasons for what the coach thought were greener pastures in a dual role as coach and GM with the Buffalo Sabres. Spurning the man who would become the winningest coach in the game's history was a giant slip. Grundman would soon be taken to task for passing over local star Denis Savard in the 1980 draft. The bumbling continued as a succession of coaches, including Claude Ruel and Bernie Geoffrion passed behind the bench while the Canadiens raced toward mediocrity. Grundman's era was defined by turmoil and turnover. During his five year stint at the Habs helm, his failing to adequately replace those players that Bowman hinted at moving, dried up to teams depth of draft picks and youth. While some of the remaining vets had enough in the tank to give the Canadiens a surprise Stanley Cup in 1986, only two draft choices in the Grundman era, Chris Chelios and Guy Carbonneau, would have a profound effect on the teams future. After dealing future Norris Trophy winner Rod Langway, along with three other players, in a package to Washington in 1982, Grundman's coffin was prepared. He was fired in April of 1983. He last made headlines in January of 2005, when as a city councellor in Montreal, he admitted to taking bribes in a zoning scandal and was sentenced to 23 months of community service, oddly enough.

8 - Feable Returns on Aging Veterans.

As mentioned before, Grundman stuck to his plan and kept many of the teams aging stars as they passed their prime into their twilight years. Ken Dryden, Yvan Cournoyer, Serge Savard (who would become his successor), Guy Lafleur (under the Savard reign) and Jacques Lemaire all retired with no return. Guy Lapointe, Steve Shutt, and others were traded off for pitances of their worth as their play declined. Roughly half of the team that won four straight Cups were gone with little to nothing to show for it. That is sadly, the Grundman resume. When Serge Savard was named as the next GM of the team, the Canadiens were literally starting over from scratch.

7 - Humiliating Wickenheiser.

One of Grundman's better moves involved a trade that flip-flopped first round picks with the Colorado Rockies in 1980. The Rockies assumed the Habs 18th overall pick while Montreal cashed in with the first overall choice. The local media were all in favor of local product Denis Savard, but Grundman went with the consensus choice of Doug Wickenheiser, who'd scored 89 goals with the Regina Pats the previous year. The GM was raked over the coals for ignoring the local star but the hockey intelliagenca would back the belaboured GM as Wick was clearly called the more refined player at that point. 89 goals in the WHL doesn't lie. Hindsight would actually suggest that the best player in the draft was chosen 7th, Paul Coffey. Where the Canadiens thinkers goofed big time was in sitting out Wickenheiser against Savard's Blackhawks on the opening game of the season. Savard shone as the game's first star, and the Habs prodigy was stung and embarrassed. The local press never let up and the cumulative effect on Wickenheiser, as Savard's star rose, was complete humiliation. Further along, Wickenheiser was being groomed as a two-way center and kept away from Guy Lafleur as a linemate. Checks on his character were given failling grades each year, as the player progressed to become a 25 goal scorer in his third season as a 21 year old. It still wasn't good enough, especially compared to Savard's 100 point seasons. Wickenheiser was shipped in a multi-player deal the following year. Had Montreal only let him play his game, perhaps the 6' 5", 220 lb center could have lived up to his potential. First overall picks are a rare commodity to an organization, and montreal wated the only one it had in this timespan.

6 - Corey Forces His Vision Upon Savard

Serge Savard was doing quite well for the team as GM when the man who hired him, Ron Corey, began meddling in his business. Under the former defenseman, the Canadiens had won the Cup in 1986 and made a return trip to lose the final in '89. Corey's background with the Nordiques hid a thinly disguised love of the Canadiens saintly image, and he did not like what he saw. Fiery coach Pat Burns led a group of players with mounting off-ice reputations. With Claude Lemieux as the reigning NHL's public enemy number one, and the bar strip scandals involving Shayne Corson and Chris Chelios, Corey sought to purge the Habs of bad-boy images. In doing so, Corey underestimated the guts and blood contribution of these warriors to the teams overall complexion. His meddling began when he forced Savard to deal off Norris Trophy winner Chelios, who'd been named one of the team's co-captains along with Guy Carbonneau (who Corey would later also have expelled for similar reasons). When the opportunity arose for GM Savard to obtain the Hawks Denis Savard, correcting an old Grundman faux-pas, Corey saw a public relations coup in the making and ordered the deal done. The headlines made for a big splash accross the media, but Savard, Denis, was in total decline. GM Savard never hid his contempt for having to make the deal, and his relation with Corey began to sour. Corey's biggest fear, was in being eventually replaced as team president by ever more popular Savard. Many of Savard's next deals shared the same theme, and faltered for the exact same reason. GM Savard found Chelios to be a cornerstone of the team, and hardly wanted to part with him. Watching Chelios in 2007, one can only wonder, what if?

5 - Major Trades and the Captain Shuffle

In an attempt to breath offensive life and change the room atmosphere of the team, GM Savard parted with a string of players wearing the CH tattooed on their hearts. Guy Carbonneau, Eric Desjardins, John Leclair, Gilbert Dionne, Matthieu Schneider, and Kirk Muller were all dealt off for what seemed good returns at the moment, but the soul of the team had been ripped out. Finding a suitable character player to wear the "C" became an issue for the omnipresent media hounds to ponder. After Carbonneau's fickle finger salute earned him a ticket out of town, Muller filled the role briefly until traded. The team who hadn't traded a captain since 1962 was about to deal of a third in Mike Keane, generously thrown in as part of the Roy deal in 1995, simply because the team president felt an english captain was unsuitable. Ensuing captain Pierre Turgeon hung around long enough to transport a barely lit torch from the Forum to the Bell Centre before asking off the ship. Vincent Damphousse was fairly effective captain during the teams most dismal years. The combined multitude of trades and lack of leadership led to the team became ordinary, heartless, and dull in record time.

4 - The Housecleaning of 1995

With the Canadiens missing the 1995 playoffs in a strike shortened season, a panic mode set in. Team president Ronald Corey was aware of infighting amongst players on the team and wanted to make changes. GM Serge Savard preached patience, but when the 1995-96 edition of the Habs got off to an 0-5 start, Corey wanted coach Jacques Demers fired. During the 1995 calander year the Canadiens had traded away important team pieces, but those changes did little to avert the teams misfortune. Savard flatly refused to place the blame on coach Demers and refused to fire him. Corey couldn't understand that Savard was on the side of stability, and sent his GM packing as well as his coaching staff. What ensued was a debacle of major consequences that would send the team spiralling for the next decade.

3 - Hiring Inexperienced Puppets

In a bumbling showcase of ineptitude, Corey was left to his own devices and promptly hung himself as he scrambled to replace Demers and Savard overnight. It was a comedy worthy of the Maple Leafs worst missteps when Corey introduced the suitable replacements after less than a weeks search. The PR machine rolled out the BS promptly as the attributes of new GM Rejean Houle and coach Mario Tremblay were bantered about with great pomp and circumstances. They were both former Habs of glory, we were fed, so hence they must be proven winners. Initial reaction was somewhat tempered when Tremblay immediatly set a Habs coaching record by winning his first six games. Everything unravelled from there. Despite his faults, credit must go in some part to the coach who managed to steer this mess of a team into the playoffs two seasons straight. Had he been groomed for the job in any way, it might have prepared him to deal with the brick aimed at his face that he never saw coming. Houle was primarily a puppet of Corey's, who had no prior imput in the team and no one left to consult on matters of importance. He was also led blindly to his day of infamy.

2 - Dealing a Hall Of Fame Goalie on 72 Hours Notice

The Patrick Roy of 1995 was by no means a happy camper. He was essentially the captain of the team, while also being it's most controvercial dressing room member. After Roy lost an ally in Demers, his composure frittered away, making his play a shadow of its former self. Off ice issues were also at the heart of his unhappiness and he decried the trading away of several key team members. To put it point blank - he and Tremblay hated each others faces. Words exchanged between the two dated back a few years and the wounds were still open between he and the former broadcaster turned coach. No need to pour over the details of a certain December night in '95 - suffice to say only that it was destined to happen considering the relationship between the two. That was something that Corey never took into consideration upon hiring the inexperienced duo. No thought was given to repairing the burnt bridges - Roy was going to be dealt. Houle went back to the scene of a previous trade inquiry by Savard (Roy to the Avalanche for Fiset, Nolan, and Deadmarsh) and tangoed with the ever sly Pierre Lacroix and came out fleeced. In return for his franchise player, Houle was served three journeyman players at best. Little thought was given to upping the ante by negotiating with other teams, they just wanted the festering Roy scenario out of their hair as quickly as possible.

1 - The Alex Kovalev Hot Potato

The Andre Savard and Bob Gainey regimes were comparitively quiet as opposed to what had gone on in the years prior. With the Canadiens meadering towards a perenial middle of the pack team, there has been nowhere to go but up. A succession of halfway decent coaches came and went until hope sprung eternal with the announcement of Bob Gainey as the teams new GM. Both GM's have managed to stockpile a depleted farm system with a bevy of talented prospects. The Gainey era has been pretty much error and controversy free until the dark side of Alex Kovalev reared it's ugly head this past season. Has this enigmatic and moody player's situation been mismanaged? Does his personality clash with that of present coach Carbonneau? Could it be that Kovalev simply had a bad year? It is starting to look as thought the player is more bother than he is worth. Whether Gainey is able to ship him off before further internal damage is done remains to be seen. The issue is certain to remain a hot topic until it is dealt with in definitive fashion.