Preseason Game 1: Stars @ Canadiens 6-3 L
In an effort to dampen the intense excitement coming into the season, the Montreal Canadiens got doubled up on by the Dallas Stars in what initially looked a lot worse when the Stars leaped out to a 4-0 lead after just 24:04 of ice-time.
Scoring summary from NHL.com:
The game was messy, as most preseason games are, and to be honest I feel bad for the people who payed full price ($250) for platinum seats tonight. That said, although the game itself means little to nothing, there are some notes that can be taken from the game.
The Bad:
Carey Price seemed to be predicting tonight's game when he said he wasn't feeling quite right about his game yet. Two awkward looking goals went in on Carey tonight, and four goals in total. He slightly bettered last season's preseason debut, stopping 9/13 instead of 5/9 shots. Unlike last season however, there he wasn't booed off the ice, which is a marked improvement for the notably fickle Bell Centre crowd. Luckily for Habs fans, this is a trend for Price that most of us have gotten used to by now. Carey's play in preseason is usually sub-par to terrible as he uses that time to fine tune his game. By the time the season rolls around he'll be 100%.
Raphael Diaz took about half the game to start looking comfortable at this level, and although he had some slick moves in the offensive zone, he wasn't very good in the defensive zone at any point.
Hal Gill looked like he was already pacing himself for the playoffs and had several blunders.
Jeff Woywitka's goal may have given him a couple more preseason games as a Hab, but up to that point and most shifts afterwards he was busy giving Jacques Martin and the rest of the coaching staff every reason possible to cut him. Everyone he was paired with seemed to instantly struggle.
Aaron Palushaj had more nerves than anyone else to start the game, he might have been the Habs worst forward in the 1st period. He improved over the course of the game, but it really doesn't look like this is Palushaj's time to make the jump to the NHL.
Faceoffs were a big problem area for the Canadiens tonight as they won just 27%. The worst of the bunch is auditioning 4th line center Andreas Engqvist who went 0/5 as well as Plekanec who won just 6/20 and was waved out of the circle multiple times. While faceoffs aren't as important as some pundits pretend if you have good puck retrieval, those kind of numbers are unacceptable.
The invisible - Alain Berger, Brian WIllsie, Danny Masse, Andreas Engqvist, Ian Schultz (aside from a fight).
The Good:
Andrei Kostitsyn was a beast tonight. His powerplay goal put the game back within reach for a brief period in the second period. On many shifts in the last 40 minutes of the game Kostitsyn looked like Peter Forsberg in the offensive zone as he held the puck and out-battled multiple Stars players while opening up lanes for teammates.
Yannick Weber played a top notch all around game against a competition level he rarely faces, and with more ice-time than he's ever received in the NHL at 25:54. Weber was one of only two Habs defenders to record a plus rating and looked to have significantly improved his defensive zone play. Weber also looked a good measure stronger as he angled players out on the rush.
Nathan Lawson was surprisingly solid, especially right after the goalie switch. He will give Hamilton solid goaltending this season.
Alexei Yemelin was a bag of nerves to start the game, and he wasn't helped by being paired with Woywitka, but as the game went on he gathered himself quite impressively. He made several adept plays in the offensive zone, acquitted himself well in the defensive zone and finished second to Weber in overall ice-time at 21:35.
Mike Cammalleri - Tomas Plekanec - Erik Cole: It was clear that the line hasn't quite gelled yet, and both Plekanec and Cammalleri were guilty of trying to set Cole up too often instead of shooting, but the line showed flashes of how dominant it has the potential to be. Cole's goal was a snipe and he made intelligent reads all game long. Montreal made a good move to grab him in July.
Jarred Tinordi was surprisingly solid in a very similar way to how he played last year in the preseason. His positioning, puck skills and foot speed all looked to be much better than last year. He was the other defender to register a positive plus/minus rating.
Brock Trotter was up and down during the game as he alternated using his speed to give defenders fits while making smart plays, and trying to do too much. His speed and skill is evident, and he's not afraid of going to the tough areas of the ice. Of the players fighting for that 13th forward spot on the Habs roster, he seems to have the lead by a wide margin.
32 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Kostitsyn was amazing. One of the reasons I’d like to see him on a third line is how he can take over a game when facing weaker players.
Yemelin didn’t have the best game but I liked a lot of what I saw.
I thought Diaz was somewhat better than you made out but he looks more like a guy that’s going to be a leader in the AHL than an NHL player at this point.
Gill was trying to cover far too much space and that left him exposed. He’s not best suited to the sort of wide open system-less game that happens in the preseason but he also needs a defensive partner used to him that can funnel players towards Gill and cover the rest of the defensive zone while Gill locks down the high leverage areas. Playing with an inexperienced partner does not suit him
First looked like they’ll be good together, Tinordi looked very raw but showed promise, Woywitka looked absolutely terrible to start which didn’t help Yemelin.
by Stephan Cooper on Sep 20, 2011 11:48 PM EDT reply actions
All I could think while watching Gill is that he looked great last year because Subban was a $%^&ing stud.
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 20, 2011 11:54 PM EDT up reply actions
Gill is like Gomez. He is world class in a couple skills that are vital for players for his position and stinks at the rest. When he’s guarding an important area it becomes a place were opposition puck possession goes to die and he’s great at angling players into the perimeter.
He if he gets to far from the boards or the net though he’s easy to get around which lead to scoring chances tonight. His partner needs to cover more of the open ice areas so he can get closer to the boards where he’s effective, rather than in the open ice where he’s a pylon. Gorges and Subban are good at that so Gill is effective with them.
That said, the success of that pairing was probably 75-85% Subban being awesome.
by Stephan Cooper on Sep 21, 2011 12:14 AM EDT up reply actions
This is exactly what Gill is and always has been.
Put the guy in a position to succeed and he will look amazing, place him in a position where his weakness is exposed and you get the Leaf version that gets blamed for everything.
The Penguins didn’t put him on the ice with a minute to go in Game 7 of the Cup Final because he sucks, his skills fit that situation perfectly.
Hopefully we can use him in the Penguins way this year.
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 10:00 AM EDT up reply actions
With the Habs’ D depth, they have enough guys with different skills to handle what Gill can’t. And if push comes to shove PK can carry him. ;)
Agreed 100%
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 11:41 AM EDT up reply actions
And if PK isn’t available, well Gorges probably can too.
by Stephan Cooper on Sep 21, 2011 11:45 AM EDT up reply actions
my predictio .
I have high hopes for the habs this year the only thing im worried about is Markov staying healthy and defence playin defence. Gomez will be more consistant this year! Plenkanic will led habs in points all season, but dont look for defence to be regular goal scores unless there on a power play. price will have another amazing year. Habs will finish top 5 at he end of the year. Lets hope they stay healthy and consistant. Go habs Go!!!!
Pretty similar read to what I saw in brief viewings. Had to work on my car and missed the whole goal flourish in the 2nd.
Lawson was very rebound happy I thought. Oh well, he’s #3 on the depth chart, that’s generally what you get at that point.
The Stars iced a stronger lineup… more guys with NHL experience than the Habs. That said, Woywitka did look just awful out there for playing his old team, and the ex-Habs on the Stars were having fun reigniting what were truly mediocre years when they were linemates (Ryder was always better with Koivu than Ribs).
Even amongst his really quick linemates, Erik Cole looks ridiculously fast.
Puck Worlds: Chasing Pucks from here to Turku.
For Twitter Updates on Puck Worlds, follow @puckworlds. For updates plus additional witty banter from yours truly, follow @saskhab.
Lawson is definitely a little rebound happy, but he has a quick glove which is nice to see. Kind of similar in style to Robert Mayer so maybe he can help him adjust a bit better. Looking forward to seeing Budaj tonight.
Agreed about Cole, he has an extra gear similar to Gionta, but he’s better at fighting off checks obviously because he’s half a foot taller.
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 11:45 AM EDT up reply actions
I doubt we will ever see him in a regular season game in a Habs uniform. If we do, the season is likely in GIANT trouble.
by Chris Boyle on Sep 21, 2011 12:55 PM EDT up reply actions
I wouldn’t say that… 3rd stringers often get called up for temporary duty at some point. If Budaj got hurt having Lawson start once a month wouldn’t be a huge issue.
Puck Worlds: Chasing Pucks from here to Turku.
For Twitter Updates on Puck Worlds, follow @puckworlds. For updates plus additional witty banter from yours truly, follow @saskhab.
Well, if you are counting the guy sitting on the bench modeling the latest hats from the Habs boutique, than maybe, but the only way that guy touches the ice is if Price goes down for a significant amount of time.
Lawson is a scrub.
It could easily happen in practice, although most goalies are very durable. Still, freak occurences happen… Lalime got beaned by a puck while sitting on the bench. ;)
Are they really going to play Price 70 games? I thought they wanted to cut back a bit.
All I was saying is that it is unlikely we will see Lawson ever play a game for the Habs. That he is essentially AHL filler. Sanford never played one minute for the Habs, he may have dressed, but he never played in two seasons, neither did Desjardins. Marc Denis played 20 minutes.
I am not really concerned with how good he is because he is a 28 year old scrub. If something terrible happened the Habs could acquire a more adequate replacement for fairly cheap.
Goalies can get hurt in practice, but it isn’t the 80s where shots are going to do the damage, the likely culprit would be a strain or tear of a groin.
I would give Budaj 20 handpicked games based on rest and quality of opponent. 62 starts is more than enough for Price.
Ever heard of Pascal Leclaire? #cheapjoke
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 4:53 PM EDT up reply actions
Are you suggesting that Pierre McGuire is prone to exaggeration???? Scandalous!!
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 6:28 PM EDT up reply actions
BTW, I won’t ever feel bad for people rich and stupid enough to pay $250 for tickets to that game.
Puck Worlds: Chasing Pucks from here to Turku.
For Twitter Updates on Puck Worlds, follow @puckworlds. For updates plus additional witty banter from yours truly, follow @saskhab.
Well, a big part of that 2nd period flurry was a particular Stars unit getting stuck on the ice, pinned in their own zone for almost 2 minutes.
I had the scoring chances splits by periods at +1/-7, +9/-4 and +1/-3. The scoring chances scripts aren’t up yet and I haven’t cobbled mine together either, so I don’t know abeout ES/ST splits.
Ribeiro did put a beating on Woywitka/Yemelin in the 1rst, tough.
That was Kostitsyn’s shift of doom wasn’t it?
by Stephan Cooper on Sep 21, 2011 11:47 AM EDT up reply actions
Yup.
AKost looks like a middle of the pack guy against Chara, but against Fortunus et co., he can rag the puck around all night. Somebody told this to Palushaj and Willsie after the 1st and they then kept feeding the puck to AK. Not a bad strategy.
I’m really curious to see what AK can do with 13-15 minutes a night at ES against 2nd-3rd lines…
I think that might be one of the most exciting things about this season. Kostitsyn out against the lower half of team’s rosters on a consistent basis is going to be really good. And when he has a couple of NHL quality linemates to boot, it’ll be something to see.
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 1:37 PM EDT up reply actions
I think this plays heavily into the inconsistent Kostitsyn meme. He is dominant against weak players but much less so against good ones. How good he looks to the eye is probably heavily dependent on who he’s facing, more so than with guys like Cole and Pacioretty whose games a much simpler.
by Stephan Cooper on Sep 21, 2011 2:25 PM EDT up reply actions
Very true.
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 4:55 PM EDT up reply actions
Hey, looks like Yemelin finally has a SB Nation player page.
Puck Worlds: Chasing Pucks from here to Turku.
For Twitter Updates on Puck Worlds, follow @puckworlds. For updates plus additional witty banter from yours truly, follow @saskhab.
Noticed that as well, about time!
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 1:37 PM EDT up reply actions
This made me think of Chris and MathMan: http://xkcd.com/904/
Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/andrewberkshire
by Andrew Berkshire on Sep 21, 2011 7:16 PM EDT reply actions




















