Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Auto Racer Jeffrey Earnhardt Excited to Make MMA Debut

Chara Hit is League's Fault

The NHL has major consistency issues. I think we all know that. The fact Matt Cooke and Mike Richards skate freely while Trevor Gillies is suspended says it all. Gillies hit was terrible, and warranted suspension. But was it worse than Richards or Cooke's hit?

 Now we get to last night. The Boston Bruins and Montreal Canadiens played their first game since the infamous match up a few weeks before. There were a lot of fights, a lot of goals, and no one got hurt. The Bruins played a similar game vs the Dallas Stars a few days before.

 In that Stars game, Daniel Paille got suspended four games for his hit on Raymond Sawada. It was the right call. A few weeks later, the Gillies suspension. The NHL seemed to be getting their stuff together, finally. Then Colin Campbell was at the Bell Centre last night.

 And while the previous game between Montreal and Boston ended with no major injury, this was the right call. Unfortunately, this game ended differently. Max Pacioretty suffered a broken vertebrae and a severe concussion. it was also one of the fastest anyone has ever seen a stretcher come out. The referees ended the period 15 seconds early.

 All because of an interference call. Zdeno Chara hit him into the boards between the bench, face first. And the part where I have an issue is that the puck had left Pacioretty's stick almost two seconds before hand.

 That was the real mistake by Chara, not as much the hit. The reason it was dirty was because the play was over. Zdeno Chara is not a dirty player. But that play caused unnecessary harm to a player. And the league had a real chance to punish a star and send a message.

 Well they failed at that. Yet again. Their first mistake came with the Todd Bertuzzi incident, years ago. They let him back into the league. They let Cooke and Richards and Scott Stevens get away with their hits. And now these hits continue.

 Evidence proves that concussions come from when you are not expecting contact. Some of these hits have as much force as a regular hit. Here is the difference; They were blindside hits. The human brain cannot brace themselves, resulting in concussions.

 This is made evident in woman's hockey, where there is no body checking. Yet they have double the concussions of men's college hockey (credit: SBNation.com)

 How does this have to do with the Chara hit? it shows the league's consistency. I would have been fine with a Chara suspension, and I normally wouldn't have a big issue with him not being suspended. But the league has to show that this issue is one they want to stop. And they have proved yet again they really don't care.




Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

As a previously commentator said, at this point, I’m more sad than angry.

The NHL has made clear its stance on not punishing star infractions. Chara, Pronger, Ovechkin, etc. etc.

What really stings after a day is to find out the poor kid broke his neck, got a major concussion, and may never continue his career which was just budding.

by westcoasthabs on Mar 9, 2011 10:29 PM EST reply actions  

If they want to crack down on reckless hits and suspend a player like Chara to set an example, I’m all for it. But it’s clear that the league has no such plan. They hand out suspensions in reaction to injuries (and even then), or seemingly at random to prove they’re at least doing something because doing nothing would look too bad. I agree the league is at fault for tolerating dangerous behavior for too long and what happened today is the proof that there’s no intention to change that.

by Hypnotoad on Mar 9, 2011 10:38 PM EST reply actions  

Scott Stevens'

hits were all clean, but they were hard enough to knock people silly anyway. That’s the whole problem I have with this nobody-can-ever-get-hurt-ever mentality the league seems to be taking- hockey is a physical sport. People can get hurt. That’s not to say that plays like boarding and blind-side hits that, positionally, have an extremely high chance to injure shouldn’t be penalties, or that players like Bertuzzi or McSorely who went out of their way to try to kill someone should be in the league. But… you just can’t punish a clean hit in an unfortunate part of the ice.

by Hillbutton on Mar 10, 2011 7:45 PM EST reply actions  

you just can’t punish a clean hit in an unfortunate part of the ice.

Are you out of your fucking mind?

Look at the photos…arm high up against Pacioretty’s head! Chara doesn’t even take him out if there no stanchion there.

It’s not a clean hit if the player is not in possession of the puck. It all starts right there.

Get your head out the sand and quit drinking the NHL’s Kool-Aid.

by Robert L on Mar 11, 2011 4:20 PM EST reply actions  

Agreed. Many people seem to overlook the fact that Pacioretty was not in possession of the puck. If he had been, it would be a completely different story.

by Alexandre S on Mar 11, 2011 5:23 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Montreal Canadiens.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Triple_low_five_small
The Bergevin Bunch – Who should be on the Canadiens’ Shortlist?
Triple_low_five_small
Anti-GM Race: The Search for the Worst Candidate
Triple_low_five_small
Habs GM Search: My Personal Shortlist
Ts_small
Vintage Hockey Jersey Scam
Predsgame_small
So yeah...
Lokomotiv_yaroslavl_logo_small
Welcome Mount Royal Soccer to SB Nation
Triple_low_five_small
The Montreal Canadiens and the Future
Picture_1_small
Other Crazy Eklund Trade Rumours
Picture_1_small
Randy Cunneyworth's Link To Homer Simpson

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

A Glossary of Analytical Stat Terms

For those unfamiliar with common terms on EOTP such as Fenwick, PDO or relative Corsi, here is a handy explanation.

Click here to access the glossary


Managing Editor

2987845178_b30976f7f9_small Kevin van Steendelaar

Feature Editors

A_new_eotp_logo_small Robert L

P1020029_small Andrew Berkshire

Butch-montreal__2__-_copie__4__small Francis B.

Small Chris Boyle

Lokomotiv_yaroslavl_logo_small Bruce Peter

Small Stephan Cooper

Contributing Writers

Small Olivier

Jp_small Joe Pelletier

Profile_small Melissa_Boufounos