Habs Eyes On The Prize: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Once A Metro covering Red Bull New York!

Gainey Abandons GM Role In Montreal Under Curious Circumstances

Gone_gainey_medium
In the city where every possible hockey decision represents a potential controversy, it is difficult tell the smoke from the dry ice when it comes to today's decision by Bob Gainey to step down from the position of general manager of the Canadiens.

There will always be speculation attached to what occurred today and a certain "did he jump or was he pushed" stigma will always be tied to the things fans and reporters are not privy to.

Bob Gainey called it a personal decision, saying that he prefrerred to step down a bit sooner rather having to leave once it was too late.

Critics will suggest that time was imminent, others will note that with a trade deadline approaching, that the timing is rather odd and curious.

According to Gainey, he was asked by the organization for a commitment beyond this season, and was not prepared to make one.

There can be no doubt that Gainey leaves the team in better shape than when he took it over in the summer of 2003. There were a good number of high times and some low lights, as there is during any regime.

Of course, the speculation will reign supreme for weeks that Gainey was pressured into an early exit based on current player scenarios and team standing. That is the nature of Montreal to scope such extremities.

Two news bits heard today, from different sources unattached to today's event will linger in my mind.

Earlier this morning on radio station CKAC, commentator and play by play man on the station Martin Maguire was speaking of the Canadiens seemingly never ending goaltending controversy, when he made reference to some inside information concerning the trade market.

Maguire claimed that the Canadiens had and still were shopping goalie Jaroslav Halak, and that offers for him had not risen in return value. However, it appears GM's took Gainey's stance in not moving Halak as a sign that Carey Price could now be had. Offers for Price were pourring in, as per Maguire.

Maguire's colour man on those broadcasts, former QMJHL coach Dany Dube, after Gainey's announcement today, recalled a conversation he had with the GM this past summer, shortly after he had rebuilt the club through free agent signing. Dube quoted Gainey as saying something along the lines of "this is the team you will be left with," hinting that Gainey knew of the possiblity that this was his last season at the helm of the club even then.

Whatever spin the events of the day take on in the future, how many of you actually believe that the Canadiens would fire Gainey in the traditional sense, if ever it came to that?

Gainey, a lifelong Canadien, has endured a great deal during his tenure. A family man with very strong personal convictions, he has lost two precious family members in the past decade. This past summer, Gainey became a grandfather for the first time. This past weekend he surely spent some moments of the phone with Brian Burke, who's family suffered a tragedy of their own.

Perhaps given the choice, his future with a lighter workload, balancing babies on his knee seemed more enlightening than running a hockey team in a city that never forgives.

0 recs  |  Comment 21 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Gainey

Maybe some of Bob’s moves could be questionable but I’ll tell you one thing, he did the best he could for the team and for the organization. There is so much that we as fans do not see in regards to management of this team but yet we have no shortage of armchair GM’s who know the whole scoop. This is a new NHL. We are a team that has to compete with one arm tied behind the back because we have to have so much language on our team. Not saying that Having to have French players on our team is bad but when you have to make decisions not always based upon the absolute best we can get, regardless of ANY language, we will be at a disadvantage. Bob had to do both. Considering that he has improved this team during his tenure, we should all be grateful.

by Wrencher on Feb 8, 2010 6:55 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Well put, Wrencher

Bob came in and did exactly what he said he would do. He spent 2-3 years restocking the farm system, signed Alex Kovalev, and built upon the drafted talent. There were times when he seemed to make a desperate play or two, but every GM does the same (Brian Burke and Jeff Finger, anyone?). I commend Bob on his efforts. He had a plan, put it to work, and the result wasn’t half bad. Not great, but certainly a worthy tenure. And before anyone criticizes him, take a look at what the regime before him accomplished…

by westcoasthabs on Feb 8, 2010 8:33 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Jeff Finger

was Cliff Fletcher’s signing.

by Chris Boyle on Feb 9, 2010 12:09 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I can tell you that bouncing your grandchild on your knee is a very fine thing.

by Anvilclloud on Feb 8, 2010 7:16 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Guess...

This was to do with a move he wanted to make and couldn’t. Or, a move he would not make……

by markov94 on Feb 8, 2010 7:19 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

The radio guys in Calgary were saying today that at the draft last year, they caught Gainey sneaking out a maintenance door to avoid the media, and said that they should’ve known back then that the job was getting to him. It’s hard to imagine being the GM of the Canadiens in the modern environment, with the ready availability of fresh shrieking harpies 24 hours a day on TV, radio, newspapers, and the Internet, and with the pressure to win growing exponentially with each year of the franchise-record drought. I’m almost surprised he didn’t bail sooner.

Then again, maybe he’d been preparing for this all season. Jacques Martin was Pierre Gauthier’s hire in Ottawa; maybe the same’s true here.

SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there). Link now 100% less broken.

by Doogie2K on Feb 8, 2010 7:36 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

I was at that draft Dougie, and it wasn’t quite as dramatic as a maintenance door exit. Gainey just left the draft floor from the opposite side of the rink to which a crowd had gathered on both days. The Habs table was far left on the floor, and he headed straight left to the exit where the Canadiens dressing room is. I was waiting and he didn’t mingle, let’s say. One little kid intercepted him, and he signed for him.

by Robert L on Feb 8, 2010 8:03 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

No, no, this was at the hotel on the way over to the Bell Centre.

SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there). Link now 100% less broken.

by Doogie2K on Feb 9, 2010 1:19 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Well then that’s different. That is common Gainey behavior at any time in Montreal. He probably had to sneak about because he misplaced his Groucho Marx mask.

by Robert L on Feb 9, 2010 3:28 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Robert, your choice of the word “abandons” in your headline is telling of your sentiment, I suspect. You wrote that Gainey said he was asked to remain with the Habs, but I haven’t come across that quote (I didn’t see the press conference). I did read him say, however, that "At this point I’m not prepared to make a commitment of four, or five, or six more years in this position…" as if such an offer or option was even open to him?!

I definitely see what Doogie2K said above, and in that light you can’t blame BG at all for wanting to get out and focus on more simple and beautiful things in life as he nears his twilight. But in answer to your question "did he jump or was he pushed", in my opinion (to play the out-of-the-loop armchair GM described above by Wrencher) he probably decided to jump before he was pushed (or for fear of being pushed). I felt that portraying himself as someone who had all the options in the world and was not in increasingly hot water was disingenuous on the part of BG. I agree that using "abandons" rather than "steps down," "retires," or even "quits" to describe the move was most appropriate.

On another subject, I found Pierre Boivin’s comments telling of what, in my opinion, is a major problem with the Habs:

“You bet it’s important,” the team president said (referring to the importance of language as a job criterion). “French is the language spoken by 2/3, 3/4 of our fans and clients. It’s a matter of respect and sensitivity to the reality of Quebec.”

A business has only one main priority: to make money. A professional hockey team also has one main priority: to win games and championships. So which is it for the Canadiens? Does the "reality of Quebec" make those two priorities mutually exclusive in Montreal – unlike every other NHL franchise? Is Boivin afraid of alienating a portion of his customers and revenue at the expense of the team’s on ice performance? In the long run I think it’s a terrible business strategy because the team will end up failing to achieve either priority: Keep losing (and giving post-loss press conferences in French) and eventually many of the stinky baby Habs fans will move their allegiance to the new franchise in Quebec City. "Respect and sensitivity" – give me a break.

And, for the record, je m’appelle Guy Tremblay.

by true on Feb 9, 2010 1:15 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

I chose “abandon” and “did he jump / was he pushed” because Bob is leaving mid season. It’s not the way that I imagined he would conclude his Montreal time.

“The Reality Of Quebec” is a reality, and sometimes it is an unfortunate one, and other times it’s just plain fact. I’m not as offended by such things as I once was because I understand that success is twofold. One measure is on the ice, the other, the bottom line. Like it or not, it is a business and always has been. Nothing’s changed in that regard and the clientele will always remain a top priority.

That’s not to say that an anglophone could never have the run of the team, but it would take someone with a proven track record of Stanley Cup wins, a la Ken Holland to override the prejudices. And he would be condemned to win immdiately.

by Robert L on Feb 9, 2010 9:30 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I agree completely that it is a business, first and foremost for anyone with anything more than emotional stakes involved. My point was that there is a league-wide symbiosis between financial and on-ice success, but not in Montreal. Now is that an asset or a liability? Is the rest of the league wrong or are the Habs going to prevail despite this self-imposed small gene pool handicap? It’s not the 50s, 60s, 70s or 80s anymore where French Canadians contributed a hell of a solid block to the NHL. It’s 2010; the competition and financial stakes are exponentially broader and higher.

Being a lifelong Habs fan, I would love nothing more than – as once poster on a blog suggested – Guy Lafleur come in as the new GM, kick some ass and bring another few more Stanley Cups to Montreal. My problem is with the probability of that happening. Adapt (evolve) or die, is the saying. You can’t plan an economy when everyone else is following market forces.

You say it’s a reality and a fact. But what are all those loudmouth linguiphobes (which I believe is a small minority of the fan base) going to do if the Habs hire an English speaking GM or coach? Stop being Habs fans? I highly doubt it – especially if the team starts winning, being the opportunists that many fans are. As I said, they’ll stop purchasing if the team is a loser, French GM/coach or not. It’s the management that is too chicken shit to take real chances.

Sorry if I put any words in your mouth about the choice of the word "abandon," definitely must have been my own thoughts creeping in there. Have a good one, Robert. Go Habs!!

by true on Feb 9, 2010 6:37 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Sometimes I feel I’ll have to make this point until the day I die (and I’m still quite young), but hey, here goes:

It’s not a matter of genes, it’s a matter of language. Bob Gainey didn’t come from the so-called gene pool and yet was as respected, revered and thouroughly loved as a player and GM can be in this town.

Speak the language. It’s a simple proficiency the employer (the Habs) are asking for whomever is to get the job. And yes, I fully understand as far as proficiency goes, this one is tough to master and thus susceptible to turn away otherwise competent candidate we all fully agree on that point.

But it’s not a matter of genes, Bob Gainey is the very incarnation of that fact.

by Olivier on Feb 9, 2010 9:02 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

And I apologize for being a grouch about it; you make an interesting point, true, and I certainly in no way mean to be rude! (I’m just being a bit tone deaf from time to time, that’s all…)

by Olivier on Feb 9, 2010 9:03 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

To emphasize on Olivier’s point: like it or not, the Habs’ GM is a highly mediatized position and the local media are in a vast majority French. The ability to speak the French language therefore becomes a perfectly reasonable requirement of the ideally qualified candidate. Whether French is the person’s first language or not is irrelevant (see Gainey). Where said candidate comes from is equally irrelevant. Not only is Gainey from Ontario, but so is Martin!

by MathMan on Feb 10, 2010 12:26 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Mathman, both you and Robert pointed out the “like it or not” aspect of this debate. Liking the policy, or not, is a subjective argument that will keep fans going until the cows come home. The objective measure is wins and profitability, which lead to my question of how this unique set of requirements in Montreal will affect the team’s ability to compete in the league.

My unfortunate prediction is that Habs management/ownership, in trying desperately to juggle the disconnected priorities of winning a championship and maintaining profitability by staying linguistically faithful, will ultimately fail at both.

Winning must be the only priority, and with on-ice success undoubtedly comes financial success. Only the most hateful of bigots would renounce their support for the Habs if they won with a non-French speaking GM or coach. And who needs such fans, anyway?

I paint it simply, but of course it isn’t, and I agree with your point that the GM position is one that is one that comes will excessive media exposure – especially in Montreal where the vast majority of that media is French. But so is the captain position (albeit on a much lesser level), and I don’t see how Koivu ever hurt the organisation or it’s fan base? Tricky, unique, issues for our Habs, for sure.

I wonder how the Habs would be performing now had Gainey gone with Don Lever instead of JM. I was obviously with Scotty Bowman on this one, as he was quoted by Robert on this blog last March 14. And if Scotty Bowman don’t know both hockey and Montreal, I don’t know does. That said, he also suggested that Lever would be able to learn the language fairly quickly. Would Bowman be of the same opinion if Lever was from NY or Alberta and had no chance of learning French?

by true on Feb 10, 2010 2:17 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

JM was picked ahead of Lever because of experience, not language; the organisation had not had a head coach with previous NHL experience since Jacques Demers (dismissing Gainey’s two short interims) and NHL experience was identified as a primary criteria for the next guy. Though I liked the Martin hiring originally, in retrospect, I feel Martin wasn’t the right choice (frankly, I think he’s turning out to be a colossal mistake) but even if the Habs had “loosened” the language criteria (which, given that the man gives almost daily press conferences, would simply not have been very practical), Lever lacked the crucial experience requirement and so was not considered.

And given how the development of the Hamilton guys panned out under Lever, I’m not sure the origanisation was going to consider him for the position in any case. Frankly I’m quite glad he wasn’t hired.

by MathMan on Feb 10, 2010 8:25 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

And just so we’re clear on how experienced the average post-Dynasty Habs coach is, here’s a post I made last year on the subject.

SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there). Link now 100% less broken.

by Doogie2K on Feb 10, 2010 8:27 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Oliver, I stand corrected. You’re right; “gene pool” was the wrong term. I should have written “linguistic pool.” The rest of the argument still holds. An no worries, you can see that I’m obviously a grouch about some things, too…

by true on Feb 10, 2010 1:09 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Sorry, I meant Olivier. I stand corrected again!

by true on Feb 10, 2010 2:18 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I thought it was Guylaine…:-)

by microfox on Feb 9, 2010 5:00 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Montreal Canadiens.
Start posting about the Canadiens »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
SB Nation Survey + Chance to donate $500 to a charity of this community's choice
Small
"THE GLORIOUS YESTERDAYS, WHEN WE COULD NOT LOSE"
Small
GRAB A BRAIN, PROTECT A BRAIN
Small
Need To Find a Habs bar in Los Angeles
Small
WHY WE FIGHT AND THE 'REAL' FIGHT, OLYMPIC STYLE
Small
History's Trains On Time Tonight
1836_small
Get Your Habs Centennial Jerseys While They Last? [UPDATE: Pics]
New_york_rangers_small
Halak to Philly or Dallas?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Joe DiPenta won a Stanley Cup with the Anaheim Ducks in 2007. link

An Interview With Portland Pirates Defenseman Joe DiPenta

Carolina Hurricanes left wing Erik Cole, left, celebrates with Bryan Rodney and Jamie McBain (28) after McBain scored the game-winning goal in overtime against the Pittsburgh Penguins in an  NHL hockey game in Pittsburgh Saturday, March 20, 2010.  Carolina won 3-2 in overtime.(AP Photo/Don Wright)

Insert Obvious March Madness Comparison Here: Canes Beat Pens On OT Buzzer-Beater

Photo link

An Interview With Blue Jackets' Prospect Matt Calvert

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

A_new_eotp_logo_small Robert L

Editors

643c0d9c_small saskhab

Small Wamsley

2987845178_b30976f7f9_small yathehabsrule

Small Francis B.

Small Chris Boyle

Small westcoasthabs

19265_562713730494_48306084_34026103_732443_n_small myles82

Small Bruce Peter